CCT: Appeal court dismisses 15 charges against Saraki, upholds 3 for trial - Daily Nigerian
Daily Nigerian
  • Home
  • News
    Governor Bello Matawalle of Zamfara State

    Zamfara governor denies donating vehicle to bandits, suspends district heads over killings

    The late Gambo Jimeta

    BREAKING: Ex-IGP Gambo Jimeta is dead

    Yahaya Shariff

    Blasphemy: Court quashes convictions of Kano singer, 1 other

    COVID-19: Zakzaky’s wife reportedly tests positive

    COVID-19: Zakzaky’s wife reportedly tests positive

    Nigerian govt frees 4,000 prisoners under amnesty

    Nigerian govt frees 4,000 prisoners under amnesty

    ‘Yahoo boy’ bags 14-month jail term for defrauding American of N19.6m

    How prison’s comptroller collected N2.8m from applicants, witness tells court

    Diezani largesse: How ex-Kaduna Gov Yero collected N700m cash, by EFCC witness

    Diezani largesse: How ex-Kaduna Gov Yero collected N700m cash, by EFCC witness

    ISWAP never outrun Nigerian military during Marte military base attack – DHQ

    ISWAP never outrun Nigerian military during Marte military base attack – DHQ

    Number of Nigeria’s out-of-School children drop by 6.9m ― Minister

  • Politics
    BREAKING: Bayelsa governorship election nullified

    Bayelsa Assembly speaks on ‘plans’ to impeach Governor Diri

    Governor Abdullahi Ganduje of Kano State

    APC sweeps Kano LG election, winning all 44 chairmanship and 484 councillorship seats

    Uganda’s ruling party endorses President Museveni for sixth-term run

    Uganda poll: President Museveni in early lead as rival alleges fraud

    Makurdi: How armed robbers begged Priest for forgiveness while robbing him

    Gunmen kidnap ex-Bauchi lawmaker, Abdulmumuni Ningi

    Governor Yahaya Bello of Kogi State

    2023: Coalition endorses Yahaya Bello for presidency

    2023: Only competence will determine next Ebonyi governor – Indigenes

    2023: Only competence will determine next Ebonyi governor – Indigenes

    BREAKING: Obaseki joins PDP

    Certificate forgery: Obaseki hails Court verdict

    LASG Stimulus Packages: Transport union makes case for bus conductors, drivers in Lagos

    2021: Lagos PDP sets agenda for Sanwo-Olu

    Gov Makinde loses 81-year-old mother

    APC tasks Makinde on Ajimobi’s security template

  • The Nation
    Group rejects Uganda presidential election, calls for release of opposition candidate Bobi Wine

    Group rejects Uganda presidential election, calls for release of opposition candidate Bobi Wine

    Kano Hisbah reconciles 3,079 couples in 2020

    Kano Hisbah reconciles 3,079 couples in 2020

    Gov. Simon Lalong

    Plateau varsity workers threatens strike over underfunding, issues 7-day ultimatum

    Governor Atiku Bagudu of Kebbi State

    Bagudu approves N464m for women empowerment in Kebbi

    Auwal Musa Rafsanjani

    Biden’s Inauguration: Rafsanjani calls on African leaders to strengthen public institutions

    Governor Abdullahi Umar Ganduje

    Kano govt exempts judiciary staff from sit-at-home order

    COVID-19: Gombe records 7 deaths, says taskforce 

    Lagos manages 4,873 Coronavirus patients through EKOTELEMED service

    Tambuwal visits market after fire incident (1)

    Tambuwal visits Sokoto market razed down by fire, raises 12-member committee

    Nigerian govt destroys 2,000 substandard cooking gas cylinders

    Nigerian govt destroys 2,000 substandard cooking gas cylinders

  • Business
    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    Nigerian stock market extends losing streak, drops 0.07%

    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    Nigerian stock exchange market resumes with N40bn loss

    Nigeria’s lending rate to remain at 13.5 per cent – CBN

    CBN releases new framework for financial system safety, stability

    FCMB names Yemisi Edun as acting MD as paternity scandal rocks bank

    FCMB names Yemisi Edun as acting MD as paternity scandal rocks bank

    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    NSE market indicators rebound by 0.17%

    Tribunal sacks APC Rep in Cross River

    Court remands fake prophet for defrauding businessman of N1.1m in Osun

    Nigerian Stock Exchange, NSE

    NSE resumes 2021 with N459bn growth, index crosses 41,000 mark

    MD/CEO Fidelity Bank Plc Mrs Nneka Onyeali-Ikpe

    First female MD/CEO of Fidelity Bank assumes office

    ‘Repairing refineries, key to Nigeria’s economic prospects in 2021’

    ‘Repairing refineries, key to Nigeria’s economic prospects in 2021’

  • Opinion
    Pantami’s dilemma, by Gimba Kakanda 

    Pantami’s dilemma, by Gimba Kakanda 

    TRIBUTE: Dear Sam, by Hannatu Musawa

    TRIBUTE: Dear Sam, by Hannatu Musawa

    Minister of Justice Abubakar Malami

    FEATURE: 20 major achievements of AGF Malami in 2020

    LEADERSHIP publisher, late Sam Nda-Isaia

    Nda-Isaiah: A mentor extraordinaire, by Samuel Aruwan

    A portrait from a Fulani marriage ceremony. Kajuru, North-western Nigeria.

    On nomadism: The completed work of Dan Fodio, by Ismail Misbahu

    Governor Mai Mala Buni of Yobe State

    Gov. Buni: How far, so far? by Isa Sanusi

    Dear FCT Minister: A desperate call to save streets flowers, grasses, by Aisha Hamisu Abubakar 

    Dear FCT Minister: A desperate call to save streets flowers, grasses, by Aisha Hamisu Abubakar 

    Gimba Kakanda

    Shettima’s Bitter Truths to Power, by Gimba Kakanda 

    Why Ganduje should preserve Kano zoo and botanical gardens, by Prof. Alan Frishman

    Why Ganduje should preserve Kano zoo and botanical gardens, by Prof. Alan Frishman

  • Sports
    Pogba stunner sends Man Utd top with win at Fulham

    Pogba stunner sends Man Utd top with win at Fulham

    COVID-19: 2 more Australian Open players test positive

    COVID-19: 2 more Australian Open players test positive

    Barcelona captain Lionel Messi

    Messi gets 2-game ban

    COVID-19: Four more Australian Open participants infected

    COVID-19: Four more Australian Open participants infected

    New decision on Tokyo Games should come after spring, official says

    Olympics: Japan bans entry of athletes during virus emergency

    NBA Roundup: Damian Lillard nets 40 as Blazers clip Kings

    NBA Roundup: Damian Lillard nets 40 as Blazers clip Kings

    Rafael Nadal

    Nadal, Thiem suffer coaching setbacks ahead of Australian Open

    Sabalenka wins season-opening tennis title in Abu Dhabi

    Sabalenka wins season-opening tennis title in Abu Dhabi

    Kano Pillars declare player missing

    Kano Pillars declare player missing

  • Features
    The Paris Agreement: where Nigeria stands five years after

    The Paris Agreement: where Nigeria stands five years after

    NITDA DG Kashifu Inuwa

    FEATURE: How Nigeria’s digital Agric potentials will be harnessed through NAVSA

    GITEX 2020: How Nigerian start-ups thrilled investors, showcased ‘problem solving’ innovations

    GITEX 2020: How Nigerian start-ups thrilled investors, showcased ‘problem solving’ innovations

    A screenshot from a video captured when the vehicle was burning

    EXCLUSIVE: How GTBank staff, CBN official burnt bullion van, ‘stole N70m’ in Kano

    National University Commission

    Proliferation of universities: Blessing or curse to Nigeria?

    Refugee Commission: Sen. Basheer’s Midas touch on victims of displacement

    Refugee Commission: Sen. Basheer’s Midas touch on victims of displacement

    Dr. Usman Mohammed Adis

    Dr. Usman Adis: Rescuing healthcare service delivery in Nasarawa

    Chief of Air Staff inaugurates officers’ quarters in Calabar

    Insecurity: CAS Abubakar’s critical decisions for critical times

    Kashifu Inuwa: The troubleshooter, by Mohammed Saleh Manzo

    NITDA: Kashifu’s ‘disruptive drive’ towards Digital Nigeria

  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    Governor Bello Matawalle of Zamfara State

    Zamfara governor denies donating vehicle to bandits, suspends district heads over killings

    The late Gambo Jimeta

    BREAKING: Ex-IGP Gambo Jimeta is dead

    Yahaya Shariff

    Blasphemy: Court quashes convictions of Kano singer, 1 other

    COVID-19: Zakzaky’s wife reportedly tests positive

    COVID-19: Zakzaky’s wife reportedly tests positive

    Nigerian govt frees 4,000 prisoners under amnesty

    Nigerian govt frees 4,000 prisoners under amnesty

    ‘Yahoo boy’ bags 14-month jail term for defrauding American of N19.6m

    How prison’s comptroller collected N2.8m from applicants, witness tells court

    Diezani largesse: How ex-Kaduna Gov Yero collected N700m cash, by EFCC witness

    Diezani largesse: How ex-Kaduna Gov Yero collected N700m cash, by EFCC witness

    ISWAP never outrun Nigerian military during Marte military base attack – DHQ

    ISWAP never outrun Nigerian military during Marte military base attack – DHQ

    Number of Nigeria’s out-of-School children drop by 6.9m ― Minister

  • Politics
    BREAKING: Bayelsa governorship election nullified

    Bayelsa Assembly speaks on ‘plans’ to impeach Governor Diri

    Governor Abdullahi Ganduje of Kano State

    APC sweeps Kano LG election, winning all 44 chairmanship and 484 councillorship seats

    Uganda’s ruling party endorses President Museveni for sixth-term run

    Uganda poll: President Museveni in early lead as rival alleges fraud

    Makurdi: How armed robbers begged Priest for forgiveness while robbing him

    Gunmen kidnap ex-Bauchi lawmaker, Abdulmumuni Ningi

    Governor Yahaya Bello of Kogi State

    2023: Coalition endorses Yahaya Bello for presidency

    2023: Only competence will determine next Ebonyi governor – Indigenes

    2023: Only competence will determine next Ebonyi governor – Indigenes

    BREAKING: Obaseki joins PDP

    Certificate forgery: Obaseki hails Court verdict

    LASG Stimulus Packages: Transport union makes case for bus conductors, drivers in Lagos

    2021: Lagos PDP sets agenda for Sanwo-Olu

    Gov Makinde loses 81-year-old mother

    APC tasks Makinde on Ajimobi’s security template

  • The Nation
    Group rejects Uganda presidential election, calls for release of opposition candidate Bobi Wine

    Group rejects Uganda presidential election, calls for release of opposition candidate Bobi Wine

    Kano Hisbah reconciles 3,079 couples in 2020

    Kano Hisbah reconciles 3,079 couples in 2020

    Gov. Simon Lalong

    Plateau varsity workers threatens strike over underfunding, issues 7-day ultimatum

    Governor Atiku Bagudu of Kebbi State

    Bagudu approves N464m for women empowerment in Kebbi

    Auwal Musa Rafsanjani

    Biden’s Inauguration: Rafsanjani calls on African leaders to strengthen public institutions

    Governor Abdullahi Umar Ganduje

    Kano govt exempts judiciary staff from sit-at-home order

    COVID-19: Gombe records 7 deaths, says taskforce 

    Lagos manages 4,873 Coronavirus patients through EKOTELEMED service

    Tambuwal visits market after fire incident (1)

    Tambuwal visits Sokoto market razed down by fire, raises 12-member committee

    Nigerian govt destroys 2,000 substandard cooking gas cylinders

    Nigerian govt destroys 2,000 substandard cooking gas cylinders

  • Business
    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    Nigerian stock market extends losing streak, drops 0.07%

    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    Nigerian stock exchange market resumes with N40bn loss

    Nigeria’s lending rate to remain at 13.5 per cent – CBN

    CBN releases new framework for financial system safety, stability

    FCMB names Yemisi Edun as acting MD as paternity scandal rocks bank

    FCMB names Yemisi Edun as acting MD as paternity scandal rocks bank

    NSE: Investors lose N222bn in 6 hours

    NSE market indicators rebound by 0.17%

    Tribunal sacks APC Rep in Cross River

    Court remands fake prophet for defrauding businessman of N1.1m in Osun

    Nigerian Stock Exchange, NSE

    NSE resumes 2021 with N459bn growth, index crosses 41,000 mark

    MD/CEO Fidelity Bank Plc Mrs Nneka Onyeali-Ikpe

    First female MD/CEO of Fidelity Bank assumes office

    ‘Repairing refineries, key to Nigeria’s economic prospects in 2021’

    ‘Repairing refineries, key to Nigeria’s economic prospects in 2021’

  • Opinion
    Pantami’s dilemma, by Gimba Kakanda 

    Pantami’s dilemma, by Gimba Kakanda 

    TRIBUTE: Dear Sam, by Hannatu Musawa

    TRIBUTE: Dear Sam, by Hannatu Musawa

    Minister of Justice Abubakar Malami

    FEATURE: 20 major achievements of AGF Malami in 2020

    LEADERSHIP publisher, late Sam Nda-Isaia

    Nda-Isaiah: A mentor extraordinaire, by Samuel Aruwan

    A portrait from a Fulani marriage ceremony. Kajuru, North-western Nigeria.

    On nomadism: The completed work of Dan Fodio, by Ismail Misbahu

    Governor Mai Mala Buni of Yobe State

    Gov. Buni: How far, so far? by Isa Sanusi

    Dear FCT Minister: A desperate call to save streets flowers, grasses, by Aisha Hamisu Abubakar 

    Dear FCT Minister: A desperate call to save streets flowers, grasses, by Aisha Hamisu Abubakar 

    Gimba Kakanda

    Shettima’s Bitter Truths to Power, by Gimba Kakanda 

    Why Ganduje should preserve Kano zoo and botanical gardens, by Prof. Alan Frishman

    Why Ganduje should preserve Kano zoo and botanical gardens, by Prof. Alan Frishman

  • Sports
    Pogba stunner sends Man Utd top with win at Fulham

    Pogba stunner sends Man Utd top with win at Fulham

    COVID-19: 2 more Australian Open players test positive

    COVID-19: 2 more Australian Open players test positive

    Barcelona captain Lionel Messi

    Messi gets 2-game ban

    COVID-19: Four more Australian Open participants infected

    COVID-19: Four more Australian Open participants infected

    New decision on Tokyo Games should come after spring, official says

    Olympics: Japan bans entry of athletes during virus emergency

    NBA Roundup: Damian Lillard nets 40 as Blazers clip Kings

    NBA Roundup: Damian Lillard nets 40 as Blazers clip Kings

    Rafael Nadal

    Nadal, Thiem suffer coaching setbacks ahead of Australian Open

    Sabalenka wins season-opening tennis title in Abu Dhabi

    Sabalenka wins season-opening tennis title in Abu Dhabi

    Kano Pillars declare player missing

    Kano Pillars declare player missing

  • Features
    The Paris Agreement: where Nigeria stands five years after

    The Paris Agreement: where Nigeria stands five years after

    NITDA DG Kashifu Inuwa

    FEATURE: How Nigeria’s digital Agric potentials will be harnessed through NAVSA

    GITEX 2020: How Nigerian start-ups thrilled investors, showcased ‘problem solving’ innovations

    GITEX 2020: How Nigerian start-ups thrilled investors, showcased ‘problem solving’ innovations

    A screenshot from a video captured when the vehicle was burning

    EXCLUSIVE: How GTBank staff, CBN official burnt bullion van, ‘stole N70m’ in Kano

    National University Commission

    Proliferation of universities: Blessing or curse to Nigeria?

    Refugee Commission: Sen. Basheer’s Midas touch on victims of displacement

    Refugee Commission: Sen. Basheer’s Midas touch on victims of displacement

    Dr. Usman Mohammed Adis

    Dr. Usman Adis: Rescuing healthcare service delivery in Nasarawa

    Chief of Air Staff inaugurates officers’ quarters in Calabar

    Insecurity: CAS Abubakar’s critical decisions for critical times

    Kashifu Inuwa: The troubleshooter, by Mohammed Saleh Manzo

    NITDA: Kashifu’s ‘disruptive drive’ towards Digital Nigeria

  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Daily Nigerian
No Result
View All Result

CCT: Appeal court dismisses 15 charges against Saraki, upholds 3 for trial

by Jaafar Jaafar
December 12, 2017
in Uncategorized
0
My trial at CCT will fail, Saraki says

Senate President Bukola Saraki in the dock

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp
tiamin rice

The Court of Appeal, Abuja Division has dismissed 15 out of 18 counts of false assets declaration charges brought against the Senate President, Bukola Saraki by the federal government for being incompetent in the face of the law.

The Court, however, remitted three count charges to the Code of Conduct Tribunal to conduct a retrial of Mr Saraki so as to enable him defend himself properly on the charges.

The appellate court in the appeal filed by the federal government against the decision of the code of conduct tribunal which discharged and acquitted the senate president on the 18 count charge in a ruling on no case submission delivered in June this year said that Mr Saraki has to make some explanations on the three counts only.

Read Also: Appeal Court affirms APC's Isah Jibrin as Kogi East Senator, dismisses Atai Aidoko's appeal

Justice Tinuade Akomolafe-Wilson in the 70-page unanimous judgment held that there was no evidence to substantiate the 15 out of the 18 counts as valid charges.

The judge however held that on counts 4,5 and 6 bothering on the purchase of house 17 A and B at McDonald Street, Ikoyi Lagos by the Senate president, the prosecution was able to establish a prima facie case against Mr Saraki.

Specifically, the appellate court held that the prosecution established that there were discrepancies in the claims on the asset declaration forms as to how the two houses in Ikoyi were acquired.

The Appeal Court held that the senate president needs to provide explanations to the discrepancies established by the prosecution that the properties he claimed were bought from sales of rice and sugar in his asset declaration form were bought from loans acquired from a commercial bank.

The court concluded that credible evidence was led by the prosecution on counts 4,5,6 to warrant the defendant to be called upon to defend himself on how he acquired the properties disclosed in the three counts.

Justice Akomolafe-Wilson said that from the totality of the evidence adduced at the tribunal, it was proved beyond reasonable doubt that the 15 counts knocked off were based on hearsay evidence that have no probate value.

The court further held that the information supplied in the report used to prepare the charge by the federal government against Mr Saraki did not link Mr Saraki directly with the charges as required by law.

The appellate court held that the federal government erroneously came to the conclusion that the onus to prove the 15 charges was on Mr Saraki whereas it is an established fact that the party that alleges must be the one to prove beyond reasonable doubt.

The court faulted the federal government on the claim that Mr Saraki collected salaries and emoluments from Kwara State government after he had left office as the executive governor of the state adding that it was a big surprise that no single witness was invited from Kwara State to prove the allegation.

The court also took swipe at the prosecution on the allegation that Saraki operated foreign account while he was in office as a state governor but called no witness to establish the allegation in line with section 37 of the Evidence Act.

 

In the 15 count charges that were dismissed, the court held that they were substantially based on hearsay that does not drive value from merit adding that in a criminal trial, evidence base on hearsay is inadmissible in law.

“On this point the federal government failed in the allegation of operation of foreign account by the defendant as no foreign bank account was linked to the defendant while also no direct evidence was obtained from Kwara State government to establish the allegation of payment of salaries to Mr Saraki after he had left”, the Judge said.

The appeal court further held that the 48 documents tendered by the federal government and admitted by the tribunal were not from the appropriate sources that were supposed to tender them before they could be admitted in line with provisions of the law.

Having established prima facie case against Mr Saraki in respect of counts 4,5 and 6 which bothered on the properties at McDonald Street, Ikoyi – Lagos, the court said that the tribunal should conduct trial so as to arrive at a just conclusion on the 3 charges instead of dismissing them at a no case submission stage.

“In conclusion, we find no merit in 15 out of 18 count charges brought against the defendant by the complainant and we hereby uphold the decision of the tribunal delivered in June this year on the finding”.

“On the remaining three, it is hereby ordered that counts 4,5 and 6 be remitted to the tribunal for retrial to enable the defendant offer explanations where necessary”.

The federal government had on September 11, 2015 filed 13 count charges on false assets declaration against Mr Saraki and later amended the charge and increased the counts to 18.

During the trial, 4 witnesses were called and 48 documents were tendered by government to establish the case of false assets declaration against Mr Saraki.

However, at the close of the prosecution’s case, Mr Saraki made a no case submission to the effect that he was not linked directly with any of the charges and that the charges were based on hearsay.

The tribunal headed by Danladi Yakubu Umar in his ruling on the no case submission delivered in June this year, upheld Mr Saraki’s claim that the charges were based on hearsay and discharged and acquitted him from the trial.

The federal government felt dissatisfied with the decision of the tribunal and approached the court of appeal with a prayer that the decision of the tribunal be set aside on the ground that there was a miscarriage of justice.

Meanwhile, the Senate President has indicated his readiness to approach the Supreme Court to challenge the validity of the three count upheld by the court of appeal against him.

His counsel, Paul Usoro who is a SAN said that the judgment would be studied and that the apex court will be invited to adjudicate on the three charges with a view to get them nullified.

Counsel to the federal government Rotimi Jacobs SAN also said that the legal team of government will study the judgment and decide the next line of action.

birthday

Subscribe to Our VIP Newsletter

Tags: Appeal courtBukola SarakiCCT
Previous Post

Kano to construct N2.2bn worth of classrooms

Next Post

Tillerson: My failure if US resorts to force on North Korea

Related Posts

Governor Bello Matawalle of Zamfara State
News

Zamfara governor denies donating vehicle to bandits, suspends district heads over killings

January 21, 2021
The late Gambo Jimeta
News

BREAKING: Ex-IGP Gambo Jimeta is dead

January 21, 2021
Yahaya Shariff
News

Blasphemy: Court quashes convictions of Kano singer, 1 other

January 21, 2021
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact Us
Email:
[email protected] [email protected]
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • News
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Opinion

© 2019 Daily Nigeria News - All Rights Reserved

en English
af Afrikaanssq Albanianam Amharicar Arabichy Armenianaz Azerbaijanieu Basquebe Belarusianbn Bengalibs Bosnianbg Bulgarianca Catalanceb Cebuanony Chichewazh-CN Chinese (Simplified)zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)co Corsicanhr Croatiancs Czechda Danishnl Dutchen Englisheo Esperantoet Estoniantl Filipinofi Finnishfr Frenchfy Frisiangl Galicianka Georgiande Germanel Greekgu Gujaratiht Haitian Creoleha Hausahaw Hawaiianiw Hebrewhi Hindihmn Hmonghu Hungarianis Icelandicig Igboid Indonesianga Irishit Italianja Japanesejw Javanesekn Kannadakk Kazakhkm Khmerko Koreanku Kurdish (Kurmanji)ky Kyrgyzlo Laola Latinlv Latvianlt Lithuanianlb Luxembourgishmk Macedonianmg Malagasyms Malayml Malayalammt Maltesemi Maorimr Marathimn Mongolianmy Myanmar (Burmese)ne Nepalino Norwegianps Pashtofa Persianpl Polishpt Portuguesepa Punjabiro Romanianru Russiansm Samoangd Scottish Gaelicsr Serbianst Sesothosn Shonasd Sindhisi Sinhalask Slovaksl Slovenianso Somalies Spanishsu Sudanesesw Swahilisv Swedishtg Tajikta Tamilte Teluguth Thaitr Turkishuk Ukrainianur Urduuz Uzbekvi Vietnamesecy Welshxh Xhosayi Yiddishyo Yorubazu Zulu
cosgrove
atrk